If you aren’t a fan of red light and speed cameras you wouldn’t be alone. They’ve been the subject of controversy in communities to the degree that some have stopped using them. For example, Texas banned red light cameras in 2019. On the other hand, California is currently exploring the use of speed cameras and if passed, a bill introduced in March could legalize them. (However, a previous attempt to get speed cameras in San Jose and San Francisco was defeated in 2017.)
Groups: Red Light and Speed Cameras Save Lives
Safety groups like AAA, Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety, the Governors Highway Safety Association (GHSA), the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and the National Safety Council (NSC) are proponents of the cameras, calling them powerful tools to reduce crashes. But aware of the opposition, they note that they must be integrated carefully to maintain community support.
To that end, they’ve joined forces to come up with a new checklist they say can serve as a roadmap for communities that are establishing or expanding automated enforcement programs.
“Research by IIHS and others has shown consistently that automated enforcement curbs dangerous driving behaviors and reduces crashes,” says IIHS President David Harkey. “We hope this document developed with our highway safety partners will help communities take full advantage of this tool.”
- The safety group’s site speed as one of the biggest dangers on the road. In 2019, 9,478 deaths — more than a quarter of all traffic fatalities — occurred in speed-related crashes. Safety experts say higher speeds make crashes more likely and more severe. Even as states have raised speed limits in recent years, drivers have continued to exceed those limits.
- Red Light Running
- Red light running, meanwhile, kills hundreds of people and injures tens of thousands every year. In 2019, 846 people were killed and an estimated 143,000 were injured in red light running crashes. Most of those killed were pedestrians, bicyclists and people in other vehicles and not the red light runners or passengers riding with them.
“Red light running and speeding are known killers on our roads,” says Advocates President Cathy Chase. “Well-designed and implemented automated enforcement programs can deter these hazardous driving behaviors and reduce crash deaths and injuries. They can also provide an equitable, neutral option for upgrading safety. We urge states and localities to use this checklist together with road safety infrastructure improvements to help protect motorists, bicyclists, pedestrians and other vulnerable road users.”
Current Camera Use
The safety groups say despite the fact evidence supports the effectiveness of camera enforcement, the devices are not as widely used as they could be:
- Red Light Cameras:
- Some 340 U.S. communities currently operate red light cameras, down from more than 500 during 2011-14.
- Speed cameras:
- These cameras are less widespread, but their use has been going up slowly. Currently, 159 communities have automated speed enforcement programs.
The new checklist builds on one for red light cameras that was introduced in 2018 by AAA, Advocates, IIHS and NSC.
“We know from the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety’s research that more than two people are killed every day on U.S. roads by impatient and reckless drivers blowing through red lights,” says Jill Ingrassia, AAA’s executive director of advocacy and communications. “Automated enforcement can play a role in a comprehensive strategy to address dangerous driving behaviors and improve traffic safety for all road users. This new set of best practice guidelines is an excellent starting point in helping jurisdictions ensure these programs are well-designed, data-driven, transparent and equitably implemented.”
Impact of Pandemic
The addition of speed cameras to the checklist comes amid a growing awareness of the role speed plays in traffic deaths. As U.S. roads emptied out during the first part of the COVID-19 pandemic, those who remained on the road began speeding more frequently, resulting in more fatalities even amid a decrease in driving.
“After a year in which excessive speeding became commonplace nationwide and in the midst of a historic surge in pedestrian fatalities, we need to be considering all options to get drivers to slow down,” says GHSA Executive Director Jonathan Adkins. “States and communities should use this new resource to integrate automated enforcement into a comprehensive strategy to combat dangerous speeding.”
Addressing Community Concerns
The checklist aims to address some common concerns about cameras. The groups say public support for the programs can erode when they are poorly run or when people believe their purpose is to generate revenue rather than to prevent crashes.
“Automated enforcement is proven to reduce speeds and save lives as one tool in the safe system approach,” says Lorraine Martin, president and CEO of the National Safety Council and chair of the Road to Zero Coalition. “With inclusion of equity, transparency and community participation as critical planning and implementation components, the new automated enforcement checklist will enable stakeholders to focus on safety rather than financial gain and to address speed, reduce red light running and improve mobility.”
The groups say the checklist makes it clear that safety and transparency should guide all decisions about camera programs. If the cameras are doing their jobs, communities should expect revenue to decline over time as fewer drivers violate speed limits or run red lights. Any obvious problems with sightlines, signage or signal timing that are keeping drivers from obeying the law should be corrected before cameras are installed.
They also say it’s important to have public input by convening an advisory committee. It would be made up of various stakeholders such as law enforcement, victim advocates, civil rights advocates, school officials and residents to help make decisions about guiding principles and other aspects of the program.
Finally, the groups say automated enforcement is just one tool that should be used to make roads and intersections safer. They say roadway design improvements and other changes should also be considered.