How To Determine If A Diesel Engine Is Right For You


Image
For many years on my radio show, I have said the United States should go the way of the Europeans and offer more diesels in cars and SUVs. When I get a high mileage driver on the show, I almost always recommend a diesel model and explain that a diesel engine will generally go 300,000 miles or more without major issues if you do routine maintenance.

Diesel Engines and Fuel Economy

Recently, a caller asked me why diesels run so much longer, and I was sort of stumped. Between my own research, talking to professionals, and listener feedback, I am now more convinced than ever that diesel really is the way to go for many people.

Fuel economy is certainly an issue and diesels tend to do very well. VW has a great lineup of diesel cars that do well over 40-miles per gallon. Audi, BMW, and Mercedes Benz all have cars and SUVs that have diesels, and there are a lot of new entries on the horizon, like a Chevy Cruze diesel, and a Mazda 6 diesel. Then, of course, we have a lot of diesel choices in heavy-duty pickups.

Diesel Engines and Longevity

As for longevity, there are a couple of reasons diesels last so much longer. One is, diesel engines are built beefier. Gas engines have spark plugs which cause the mixture of fuel and air to ignite in the cylinders. Diesels are higher compression engines, meaning it squeezes the air until it builds up enough heat, then injects the diesel fuel into the cylinder. This causes it to ignite on its own, which is a much more powerful explosion than the gas setup.

The other big issue is that diesels turn much lower RPMs than gas engines do. The diesel achieves higher torque at a much lower speed, so itís operating at much lower rpm [revolutions per minute] a greater percentage of the time than gasoline engines. The lower engine speed translates into fewer times a piston has to move up and down, the fewer times a valve must close, and so forth. All these things happen a lot, but not as often as they do in a gasoline engine. Lower RPMs mean longer engine life.

Every case is different and you must calculate your own miles driven, the higher cost of a diesel, and the higher cost of diesel fuel. Some cars and SUVs make really good sense, however. A recent study published in Forbes looked at the 2012 GL350 Bluetec diesel versus the gas equivalent, the GL450. Over 5 years, the diesel owners will spend $10,100 less than the owners of the gas Mercedes.

Why Diesel Engines Get A Bad Rap

Many people today remember the first diesel cars that got here, they were slow, smelly, and most of all loud. Those days are gone. The new diesels have incredible torque, are so quiet you can barely hear them run, and in many cases emit fewer pollutants than gas engines. With most diesels being turbocharged today, you can get a smaller, more fuel-efficient engine, with more horsepower.

People also think that diesels cost more to maintain, but experts say it is about a wash. Diesels do not have spark plugs, spark plug wires, or a distributor. The downside is that diesels hold more oil and the oil changes cost more. Overall, maintenance costs appear to be about the same.

Diesels are not for everyone, but neither are hybrid and electric vehicles. It is just another alternative that might be well worth considering.

Photo Credit: welcomia/Shutterstock
There haven't been any comments left on this blog yet. Be the first to add one!.