Is Buying a Loaner Car a Good Decision?

The Pros and Cons of Loaner Car Buying

buying a car road sign
Photo Copyright: argus/
I have had a lot of people ask me in the past couple of years if buying a loaner car is a good idea. We have seen many dealers recently ramp up their loaner fleets, and there are a number of reasons why.

First, automakers have recalled millions of cars over the past couple of years, and they know to get people in to make those repairs, they must provide them with a loaner, especially if the recall is of the serious nature that can cause bodily harm. The automakers cannot force a dealership to offer loan cars, so they have all come up with ways to entice the dealers to offer loaners. General Motors has been one of the most aggressive in offering dealers money to offer loan cars or increase their loaner car fleet.

One interesting side effect of loaners that was quickly discovered was it led to sales. Someone brings his or her car in for service or a recall, and a savvy dealer will give him or her a loaner similar to his or her own car, so the customer can experience the new technology, interior refinements, and increased fuel economy. Some dealers even leave sales numbers in the service customerís car, which is easy to do since they have your trade-in in the shop.

Today, many automakers pay a flat fee to the dealerships to place vehicles in loaner status. On top of that, they reimburse the dealerships with a daily fee for every day a customer is in a loaner. Some dealers apply the factory reimbursement and the factory-to-dealer incentive to the car itself to lower their cost and make the loaner cars easier to sell.

Whatís New

As of late, something new I have seen is automakers not only paying the dealers to have loan cars but when they go to sell them, these cars then also qualify for the† factory rebates and 0% financing the new cars get. Up until recent times, loaner cars were titled, registered, and thus considered new. Today, most dealers consider their loaner cars to be demos.

Can you save money buying a loaner car?

Usually, the answer is yes, a lot of money. For instance, I have a large Chevy dealer in my network that has offered as much as 30% off MSRP on several models of loaner cars, and they cannot come close to that on a brand new car. This particular dealership is running a loaner fleet of 300 vehicles most of the time, and that includes some of their most popular models like Silverado, Tahoe, Camaro, Suburban, and Malibu, in addition to some of their smaller cars. When you are shopping online or in the newspaper, youíll notice many of the best deals out there say ďdemoĒ next to the price. Odds are good this is a loaner vehicle, which is fine, but that is why the price looks so attractive.

Any downside to buying one a loaner car?

Not really, but consider the mileage, as they can vary greatly. Most loan cars programs require the dealer to leave the vehicle in loaner service for a minimum of 90 days. In that time, some will have 1000 miles on them, others could have 6000 miles. If you have choices, go with the lowest mileage vehicle that fits your needs. Youíll want to look a loaner car over carefully, in good light. You are looking for door dings, windshield chips, interior damage, and uneven tire wear. Be sure to ask, too, how the factory warranty is affected since it has mileage and warranty time expired. Car companies do it differently, so make sure you understand how it works.

These days, you can often save thousands on a loaner car versus getting a brand new car just like it. Just be careful.

Related Articles
Car Pro Advice: Buying At One Dealership, Servicing Elsewhere
A nice Los Angeles listener called us wanting to use my car buying system, but it was quite a distance in heavy traffic. She didnít mind the drive to get a new car, but servicing was going to be a rea... More ›
Car Buying Tips For Growing Families
Not a week goes by on the Car Pro Radio Show that we donít hear from expectant parents who need a new or larger car due to a new addition to the family. Making this decision can be stressful, but at t... More ›
Beware The False Dealership Ads
The Car Pro Show prides itself on pointing our listeners to the good Car Dealers that are part of the show. Our sponsors and recommended Car Pro Certified Dealers are hand-picked and closely scrutiniz... More ›
How First-Time Car Buyers Should Shop For A New Vehicle
It is an exciting time and a right of passage to go out and get that very first brand new car. Most first-time car buyers do all their research on the internet before ever actually stepping foot in a... More ›
My 2018 Lexus RX 350 (20,000 miles) lease expires in Nov 2021. Thinking of moving to Porche Macan or Cayenne. Your thoughts on these vehicles?
The Car Pro
Iíve not had the Macan in a long time, but I have a Cayenne myself currently and love it.

Jerry Reynolds
I'm consider the purchase of a loaner BMW and the car has been in service for about 6 months. How do I calculate the loss of 1/6 of the warranty when I try to place a value on the car? The car has about 4500 miles on it and the original factory warranty is 3 years 36,000 miles.
The Car Pro
Usually loaner cars are sold as CERTIFIED and that will extend the warranty past the original one. Check with the dealer to verify that, just to be sure, but Iíd bet that is the case.

Jerry Reynolds
When does the a warranty start on a dealership demo vehicle that is now for sale as a new, never been titled vehicle?
The Car Pro
When it is put into service as a demo or loaner, so you lose what time and what miles it was in use.

Jerry Reynolds