Will Paying Cash Save You Money at the Car Dealership?

Photo Credit: chairoij/Shutterstock.com
We get this question often: ďWill I get a better price by paying cash for my next car?Ē While there was a time when the answer was yes, today the opposite is actually true. I pull back the curtain below and tell you why this is true.

Paying Cash vs Financing

You read that right, you can often get a better price by financing the car with the dealership from which you are purchasing.

Thinking back to my years in the retail auto industry, I ran across a lot of people who wanted to throw around the fact that they were paying cash, and were determined that they should get some sort of special deal because of that. The truth was, as a car dealer, I didnít really care how we got our money. Whether cash, credit union, bank or one of our finance sources, we got our money quickly, often the same day, so waving a blank check in front of me did not carry any weight when it came to pricing my vehicle.

Finance Rebates

A few years ago, and even more so today, many of the captive finance sources (Ford Credit, GM Financial, Toyota Financial Services, etc.) began offering extra rebates for financing with them. Iíve seen those amounts as large as $1500. Diehard cash buyers are often put off by this and get angry with their car dealer, but the truth is, the dealer cannot control this. There is an easy way to get around it, however.

The finance companies offering the rebates are enticing you to finance with them, of course, to make a return through interest rates. They are hoping that you will decide to keep the loan so they can make money. In these cases, the savvy buyer will proceed with financing the car, get the benefit of the financing rebate, and simply pay the car off in full before the first payment is due. You get the full benefit of the extra rebate and get to write a smaller check. The finance companies know a lot of people are going to do this and they are fine with it, but others will not go through the process.

First Three Payments

One important note: dealers like to tell you to make the first three payments before you pay the car off. Dealers are paid a flat fee in many cases, itís normally a couple of hundred dollars. That flat fee is charged back to them if the consumer pays off his or her car before three payments are made, but by law, you can pay it off at any time.

Getting a better price in the case of paying cash even when there are no additional rebates just isnít true, not anymore at least. The last figure I saw nationwide showed that dealers average around $1000 in finance income from every car they sell. These profits are derived from the sale of extended warranties, credit life insurance, gap insurance, etc.

Bottom Line

Going back to my days as a dealership owner, when we were on a tight deal, meaning we were at the point of parting ways with the customer and having a no-sale, I would ask how the customer was paying for the car. If he or she were financing with us, I would accept the deal in hopes of making a profit on a warranty or some other product. If he or she were paying cash, I would likely pass on the deal. So as you can see, paying cash was a detriment to the consumer, instead of a benefit.

Paying cash will reduce your time spent in a dealership, and you can avoid interest charges if the car you are buying does not offer 0% APR financing. However, paying cash will not necessarily guarantee you a better price, and in fact, it might cause you to pay a higher price.
Related Articles
The Truth About 3rd Party Lease Companies
A recent CarProUSA Radio Show caller started our call saying he wanted to lease a new F-150 and was going with a famous third party lease company, not affiliated with a dealership. I sort of jumped on... More ›
What To Do If You Canít Afford Your Car
I hear from listeners all the time who can no longer afford their car payments. Unfortunately, by the time they reach out to me, it is often too late.

Sometimes, especially with the pandemic, i... More ›
When You Owe More on Your Car Than Itís Worth
Usually, when we get callers who owe more on their car than its true value, they financed too long or rolled negative equity from one loan to another. One such caller owed $8000 too much on her car b... More ›
Car Down Payments & Monthly Payments Up In Q4
How much did you make for a down payment on your last car? If it was $4,500 dollars, youíd be under the current average. Down payments are up in the age of the pandemic, surpassing $4,700 in the four... More ›
I agree with the advice that paying cash isn't generally in the best interest of the customer - as it applies to the added monetary incentive for captive financing. Also, if one is going to pay cash then they might as well put as much of the price on your credit card in order to garner the cash back/rewards points. Then pay that off before it accumulates interest.

Only about 10% of the population pays cash for a car. In order to negate the 15-20% annual depreciation, most of these financially secure individuals realize the value of buying a 2 year old vehicle with low mileage and most of the original manufacturer warranty intact. There are very few incentive packages that provide that amount of purchase savings.
In one respect, a new car only depreciates quickly if the buyer sells it in the first few years. I am looking at a new car in the next couple weeks and intend to keep it for at least ten years as I have with the last few cars I have owned. What do I care about depreciation in that situation? I have enough money to write a check for the car, I certainly am not worried about the asset value of a Hyundai or Toyota.

Furthermore, a buyer has a better chance of getting the elusive "good deal" with a new car than a used vehicle. "Most of these financially secure individuals realize" that car dealers make more percentage profit on used cars than new cars. The new car pricing information is so available now to consumers that dealers rarely make much money on new car sales.

If you like turnover in your vehicles, lease them.

Just my opinions, fwiw.
The Car Pro
Spot on Jack! I ask callers constantly how long they plan to keep the vehicle. If more than 4-5 years, resale is out the window.

Thanks for adding to the conversation!

Jerry Reynolds