A pandemic and a microchip shortage don't seem to be having an impact on car shopper satisfaction, at least according to the new J.D. Power 2021 U.S. Sales Satisfaction Index (SSI) Study. Researchers say customer satisfaction with their vehicle purchase experience is holding steady year over year, despite the challenges car shoppers face due to the pandemic and its resulting supply chain disruption. J.D. Power says overall sales satisfaction remains at 789 points (on a 1,000-point scale). Satisfaction among dealers where buyers purchased their vehicle increases 2 points to 841, while satisfaction with rejected dealers declines 6 points to 632.
Car Buyers Happy With Trade-In Values
What's driving the steady car buyer satisfaction amid industry challenges? J.D. Power attributes it higher than expected trade in values. Simply put, people are happy with what they're getting for their trade-in. Researchers say buyers are getting more money for their trade-in than they expected at the time of new-vehicle purchase. Year over year, J.D. Power says the percentage of buyers who got more than they expected for their trade-in increases nine percentage points in the mass market segment and increases eight percentage points in the premium segment.
That's not to say inventory issues aren't the source of some buyer frustration (and causing them to shop other brands instead.) Satisfaction among vehicle buyers significantly decreased year over year in the inventory-related factors for website (-14 points) and at the dealership facility (-16 points).
“Despite the lack of inventory, dealerships have overcome what might be thought of as a challenging sales environment for shoppers,” said Chris Sutton, vice president of automotive retail at J.D. Power. “Right now, it’s hard to see the light at the end of the supply chain tunnel, so dealerships need to continue to sell vehicles through their inbound pipeline and help customers with special orders. However, the silver lining for customers is that trade-in values remain high and this has had a positive effect on customer sales satisfaction.”
J.D. Powers says its study also finds that satisfaction with the variety of dealership inventory significantly decreased 0.55 points (on a 10-point scale) among mass market shoppers and 0.42 points among premium shoppers during a three-month period from March through May 2021.
More Study Findings
Here are some more findings outlined by the J.D. Power press release:
- If you build new vehicles, buyers will come: Manufacturers struggling most with inventory shortages are losing shoppers to competitors. The percentage of shoppers rejecting a brand due to inventory shortages is most prevalent among domestic truck brands—Ram (37%); GMC (36%); and Chevrolet (35%). Genesis has the highest percentage of rejecters (39%) among all brands because dealerships didn’t have the exact vehicle they wanted, which is 14 percentage points above the industry average of 25%. “The good news for dealers is that 78% of rejecters who reject a dealership due to inventory shortages indicate they will consider the dealership for future vehicle purchases. In other words, they’re not blaming the retailer for an inability to find their new vehicle,” Sutton said.
- Buyers of new battery-electric vehicles less satisfied with sales experience: There is a large disparity in satisfaction among buyers of battery-electric vehicles (BEVs) and buyers of internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles. The overall buyer satisfaction index is 54 points lower for BEVs (790) than for traditional gasoline-powered vehicles (844). A cause for this is dealership personnel vehicle knowledge/expertise, with more than a full point difference in sales satisfaction between BEV buyers (7.59 on a 10-point scale) and gasoline buyers (8.72). “BEV buyers are a unique challenge for dealers,” Sutton said. “As manufacturers ready new model launches, now is the time to ramp up training and knowledge of BEVs and related services—such as charging and aftersales requirements—as buyers will undoubtedly have more questions about them.”
- Remote buyers more satisfied with digital retailing: The study finds that, among those buyers who are willing and able to purchase their vehicle without having to physically visit their selling dealer, satisfaction is much higher in both the premium and mass market segments than among those buyers who go to the dealership. “The ‘Amazon effect’ of seeing, buying and having a product delivered to your doorstep has made its way into vehicle buying and it is here to stay,” Sutton said.
- Tesla’s unofficial score improves from 2020: Tesla receives an SSI score of 815, an increase from its unofficial score of 804 a year ago. The automaker is not officially ranked among other brands in the study because it doesn’t meet ranking criteria. Unlike other manufacturers, Tesla doesn’t grant J.D. Power permission to survey its owners in 15 states where it is required. However, Tesla’s score was calculated based on a sample of surveys from owners in the other 35 states.
Study Rankings
Premium Brands
Porsche ranks highest in satisfaction with dealer service among premium brands with a score of 833. This is the third time in four years Porsche has nabbed the top spot. INFINITI (825) ranks second, followed by Lexus (820), Cadillac (814) and Lincoln (813).
“This is a fantastic response from our growing community of Porsche customers, built on the dedication and creativity of our dealers. To both I have to say a big ‘Thank you!’” said Kjell Gruner, President and CEO of PCNA. “Together with our dealers nationwide, we continue to invest in dealerships as destinations, enhancing our digital retail touchpoints and strengthening the Porsche culture and sense of community among our customer base. I am grateful to see customers feeling ever more at home and well cared for as they select their dream Porsche.”
Mass Market Brands
GMC ranks highest in satisfaction with dealer service among mass market brands, with a score of 812. Buick (806) ranks second, followed by Chevrolet (804), Dodge (796) and Nissan (795).
Most Improved Brands
Domestic brands are the most improved brands. Brands showing the greatest improvement in satisfaction scores year over year are Jeep (+24), Chevrolet (+17), Dodge (+17) and Ram (+14).
About the Study
Now in its 36th year, the U.S. Sales Satisfaction Index (SSI) Study measures satisfaction with the sales experience among new-vehicle buyers and rejecters (those who shop a dealership and purchase elsewhere).
Buyer satisfaction is based on six factors (in order of importance):
- delivery process (28%)
- dealer personnel (21%)
- working out the deal (19%)
- paperwork completion (19%)
- dealership facility (10%)
- dealership website (4%).
Rejecter satisfaction is based on five factors:
- salesperson (40%)
- price (23%)
- facility (15%)
- variety of inventory (12%)
- negotiation (10%).
The 2021 U.S. Sales Satisfaction Index (SSI) Study is based on responses from 35,387 buyers who purchased or leased their new vehicle from March through May 2021. The study is a comprehensive analysis of the new-vehicle purchase experience and measures customer satisfaction with the selling dealer (satisfaction among buyers). The study also measures satisfaction with brands and dealerships that were shopped but ultimately rejected in favor of the selling dealership (satisfaction among rejecters). The study was fielded from July through September 2021.
For more about the study click here.